Friday 6 September 2013

Rugby Championship Preview - New Zealand v Argentina



Expectation is a funny thing.  Some thrive on it, others require regular changes of underpants when placed under it.  But as the saying goes, there’s no smoke without fire – those who deal well with expectation realised that the hype is there because they really are that good.

So to say that there is a fair amount of expectation on the All Blacks, as they prefer to take on Argentina in Hamilton, is probably as much as an understatement as saying that the London riots were an inconvenience for City-dwellers.  The All Blacks are rightly regarded as the best in the world and there is always a stunned reaction when they do, occasionally, lose.  But in New Zealand to lose to the Pumas, the rookies of the competition?  That wouldn’t be unexpected, it would be out-of-this-world bizarre.  The All Blacks are welcoming back the legendary Dan Carter, who is so good that they can just drop the excellent Tom Taylor out of the squad completely to make way for him.  The depth in talent that the All Blacks have is frightening – as is the knowledge that they have yet to fully hit their stride following 2 comprehensive but not-totally convincing wins over the Wallabies.

Their opponents, Argentina, recovered from a 60 point drubbing against South Africa to run the same opponents to within a whisker of victory one week later.  If one week allows for a 60 point swing, then should Los Pumas fans be expecting a nice easy canter against the All Blacks?  Well, not quite.  They might welcome back Juan Martin Hernandez and, more importantly, their talismanic captain Juan Martin Fernandez Lobbe, but generally, across the park, the talent on the All Black bench eclipses all before it.  The one solace for the Argentines though is that, although they’re not great under pressure, they don’t half like a good underdog tag – they once again have nothing to lose.

And so a classic David v Goliath is about to take place – and although the pressure will be on the All Blacks and the vast majority will already have chalked this up as a victory for the hosts, the Argentines have every chance on pushing them close if they can get the likes of Lobbe and Mantera physically dominating their opposite numbers.  Expect one hell of a physical contest.


New Zealand Team News

Dan Carter returns for New Zealand having sat out the opening two games of the Championship due to injury. With Tom Taylor succumbing to the fly-half curse, Beauden Barrett is named amongst the replacements. And Steve Hansen has handed Francis Saili his Test debut at inside centre with Ma'a Nonu rested. In the front-row Charlie Faumuina replaces injured Owen Franks at tight-head prop with Ben Franks on the bench.

Starting Line up:  Israel Dagg; Ben Smith, Conrad Smith, Francis Saili, Julian Savea; Dan Carter, Aaron Smith; Kieran Read, Richie McCaw (captain), Steven Luatua; Samuel Whitelock, Brodie Retallick; Charlie Faumuina, Andrew Hore, Tony Woodcock.
Replacements: Dane Coles, Wyatt Crockett, Ben Franks, Jeremy Thrush, Sam Cane, Tawera Kerr-Barlow, Beauden Barrett, Charles Piutau.

Key Player

Dan Carter.  Despite two great fly half displays from Tom Taylor and Aaron Cruden, Carter still has enough credit in the back to just strut back into the All Black side.  Which, to be fair, is probably fair enough seeing as he has been the world's best player for the best part of a decade.  He won't be given an easy ride on Saturday though, as the Pumas' awesome back row will be determined to give him a rough ride on his return to action.  He'll have to demonstrate composure and get his speed of thought back to match levels as quick as he can – if he does that, then he'll set the All Blacks' far superior backline loose and simultaneously avoid a mauling, which is always a bonus.


Argentina Team News

Santiago Phelan has made four changes to the side who lost to the Boks with Lobbe returning to captain the side as he replaces the banned Senatore in their back-row. Manuel Carizza replaces Mariano Galarza at lock while Felipe Contepomi is benched in place of Santiago Fernandez. Juan Martin Hernandez returns from injury and will take over duties at fullback, shifting Lucas Gonzalez Amorosino back to the reserves.

Starting Line up: Juan Martin Hernandez; Gonsalo Camacho, Marcelo Bosch, Santiago Fernandez, Horacio Agulla; Nicolas Sanchez, Martin Landajo; Juan Manuel Leguizamon, Pablo Matera, Juan Martin Fernandez Lobbe (capitan); Julio Farias Cabello, Manuel Carizza; Juan Figallo, Eusebio Guiazu, Marcos Ayerza.
Reserves: Agustin Creevy, Nahuel Lobo, Juan Pablo Orlandi, Mariano Galarza, Benjamin Macome, Tomas Cubelli, Felipe Contepomi, Lucas Gonzalez Amorosino.

Key Player

Juan Martin Hernandez.  It doesn't seem too long ago that Hernandez was being mentioned as one of the best players in the world, even running the mighty Dan Carter close, but a run of injuries and a subsequent struggle to get his form back has meant that he hasn't quite hit those 2007 levels.  When he isn't posing about in his underpants for risqué rugby calendars, Hernandez is still one of the best in the business – with supreme vision and a wonderfully cultured boot.  If Argentina are to threaten at all, he will need to come up from fullback and get his hands on the ball as much as possible to try and create something.


Key Battle

Richie McCaw v Juan Martin Fernandez Lobbe.  The first-class openside flanker cupboard isn't exactly bare in the Southern Hemisphere is it?  These 2 blokes are 2 of the best in the business when it comes to pilfering the pill, to making un-human amounts of tackles and leading well and truly from the front – sticking their faces where most wouldn't stick their feet.  The grizzled All Black has looked mightily impressive following his return from sabbatical, and Argentina's survival and competitiveness in this contest may well rest on the returning Lobbe 'out-McCawing' McCaw.  Which is much easier said than done – but if anyone can do it, Lobbe can.


Prediction

Juan Martin Hernandez.  The Pumas looked about 1000 times more competent in their last outing than they did when they were on the end of a 60-point hiding in South Africa where, to be honest, the Orpington 2nd XV would have given them a run for their money.   But was that a performance borne out of improved attitude and application, or simply because they were at home?  It's a moot point to be honest because the All Blacks are going to win anyway, but an answer to the above question may determine by how much.  I think the Kiwis will coast this one in the 2nd half following a respectable first half showing from the visitors.  All Blacks by 23 points.
 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Share your views